As its term suggests, muck diving is all about groveling in muddy environment and generally the sites don't look attractive. It is altogether a different experience from the colours of the reef and deep blue diving. Yet, muck diving is all the rage worldwide today!
Muck diving is about slowing down and taking a closer look at the marine environment and appreciating it in a new way. There are several kinds of muck habitats. Generally, they are sandy and silty bottoms, mangrove swamps, seagrass patches, under jetties and piers and wreck bottoms. Muck diving certainly offers a great variety as each habitat has its own unique terrain, substrate and interesting array of critters and species.
Most creatures residing in the domain of muck sites are skilled masters at camouflage. They are either very small or have fascinating coloured hides to conceal themselves by having similar facades of textures and colours with their background environment. Some have the ability to burrow into sand while others possess venomous spines as defensive mechanism. The most interesting of all are those that can change their body textures and colours at will as they move around their habitat or mimic other creatures to escape predation. All these rare and bizarre-looking marine creatures are all that's driving muck lovers into an addictive craze and getting hooked on diving the muck waters!
Appreciating the art of muck environment requires perfect bouyancy and a keen eye. It is a conducive environment to fine tune your bouyancy skills. With practice and in due time, you'll enjoy and rejoice at your mastery in bouyancy control hovering just above silty bottoms without stirring a speck!
Muck diving is generally done at lower depths where the variety of species can already be found. This means prolonged bottom time for more productive encounters. I am more inclined towards muck diving due to the limitless photographic opportunities at macro. I just love macro more than wide angle as indicated by my preference of muck to deep blue diving. A good mix of both types is great but generally I find muck diving more enjoyable due to the following reasons (from my experience):
1. Muck statistically proved more encounters than deep blue diving;
2. Critters moved much slower and most of them stayed stationary even at close encounters, so there's ample time to appreciate and take the perfect shots of them;
3. Longer bottom time: because you don't exert too much energy chasing big pelagics and fighting currents here. You go slow and shallow, conserving your air and shorten your Residual Nitrogen Time such that the risk of Decompression sickness is comparatively lower and your surface interval will be shorter of course;
4. You can encounter the strangest and rarest of creatures here as well as their uncommon behaviour of mating, laying of eggs, hunting and fighting;
5. Although the muck environment is not as colourful as coral reef diving, the marine critters certainly offers a more colour variations than those dull silver, blue and black pelagics of the deep. Of course, it's nice to feed your excitement once in a while to encounter huge tornadoes of Barracudas and Jacks, schooling Hammerheads, majestic Whalesharks, gracefully flying Mantas and bizarre looking Mola Molas. But be informed that these are the rarest of encounters in the deep blue and unless you know where and when they specificially hang out (e.g Layang Layang for Hammerheads, Sangalaki for Mantas and Bali for Mola Molas), I would not recomend you to waste precious bottom time out in an unknown site searching aimlessly for these elusive pelagics. Chances of encounters based on my experience in blue diving is virtually very low and even if I see them, they are only faint blue figures in a distance that disappear almost as instantly as I spotted them (like my Hammerhead encounter in Sipadan).
It was to be another full day of fun for us. Despite retiring on the basis of a tired day the previous night, we were required to wake up as early as 6 am in the morning! Anyway the excitement of diving the muck capital of the world got me jerking out of bed at 5 am already.... Michelle and Alex was still sleeping like dead log, so I went out for a quick puff and snapped a few shots of the Sunrise in Manado Bay. It was not what I'd expected it to be... The Sun was already up and was eagerly discharging its rays upon the lands of North Sulawesi. The magnitude of brightness at 5 am sure looked like 9 am here in Singapore... I wondered how early does the sun rise... maybe 4am?
We had breakfast at 7 am and were off by 7.30 am on a 1.5 hours journey to Bitung, the capital town of Lembeh. The traffic was a pain to endure. The roads were narrow, there were lots of vehicles recklessly whooping in and out of lanes and the town of Manado was already bustling with life as early 8 am. We reached Bitung on scheduled time at about 9 am. The town of Bitung seemed quieter but the infrastracture is better developed, with wider roads, orderly marked lanes, traffic lights and better architectures of buildings. Our transport pulled over at a busy fishing port along Lembeh Strait.
Bitung is a large harbour docked with lots of fishing boats. A large smelly fish factory is situated outside the town. There were lots of unsightly rubbish floating in the waters around the port. On the eastern side of the tip of North-Sulawesi, the Lembeh Strait (Selat Lembeh) runs between the Sulawesi mainland and Lembeh island to the east and is about 16 km long and 2 km wide. The strait is constantly flushed by cold upwellings from the deep with nutrient rich waters feeding the thousands of bizarre creatures inhabiting the sites. There are some interesting white limestone walls and a few smaller islands or rocks (Batu Sandar, Sarena Kecil, Kai-nah) in the middle of the strait and a lava flow visible around Batu Angus. Lembeh island is also an interesting place with some wilderness where the Tarsius monkeys, large monitor lizards, birds and land turtles live.
We boarded our boat and head out for the first chosen divesite of the day.
This Yellow Boxfish is a tiny cute juvenile of about only 2 cm. Notice its black spots are about the size of its eyes. I was chasing this puny guy for a good 5 mins just to photograph it. It was so small that it kept zipping through holes and pipes, hiding among corals and in crevices. A tough little guy to capture on camera.

Ribbon Eels (Rhinomuraena quaesita) Ribbon Eels start life as males and gradually change sex to females as they mature. Their sex and maturity are indicated by the change in their colouration. Juvenile male eels are jet black with yellow dorsal fin and as they matured into adult males, they transformed into beautiful electric blue with yellow snout and dorsal fin(above right). When a sex change occurs, the electric blue male becomes an all yellow female(above left). The yellow females are less commonly observed as compared to the black juveniles and blue adult males. They can be observed at low depths, usually in mixed sand and rubble areas well lit by sunlight. All 3 colour phases of the Ribbon eels have the same characteristics of eractic gaping mouths continously and twitching their body in a disorganised, spasm-like movement. They are aptly named as their body is thin, long and ribbon-like. Their most distinguishable feature from other members of the moray eels are their elaborate nostril flaps which are enormously expanded, forming a scoop-like structure.
We found the old rusty oil drum but our legendary fish was not found anywhere. We scoured the vicinity carefully for quite a while but just can't find it. It was strange.... Rhinopias hardly move around and they only inch a few metres in weeks or months. They generally stay stationary for a long time even when disturbed. Our speculation was that it was either captured or dead by predation. This fish has become a scarce find in North Sulawesi in recent years.... Once found, it is a prized trophy.... Better luck next time I guessed...
The Magical Wonders and the Electrifying Awe of Muck Macro!Nudi Retreat is a wonderful site full of colours and surprises! It is a site where you can do a combination of Muck and Reef exploration. Although this is relatively a small site, the encounters are virtually limitless. It is a small protected cove with lots of beautiful soft and hard corals growing below the watermark under the cliff face. Extending out to the strait is the usual nice sandy black volcanic muck.
We started the dive further out of the protected cove and straight into muck diving. Creatures abound boldly in the open sands, confident of their camouflage or flashed vivid bright warning colours of toxicity to discourage would be predators. The cliff at this site extends underwater to a depth of about 25m vertically, giving us an opportunity at a mini wall dive. Seafans, sponges and other soft corals bloomed among the walls, showcasing myriad of amazing creatures, resulting in colours extraordinaire.
Dive Site: Nudi RetreatLocation: Lembeh StraitVisibilty: 10 mTemperature: 27°CMaximum Depth: 25.2 m
Bargibant's Pygmy Seahorse (Hippocampus bargibanti)The Pygmy Seahorse has a short snout, rounded knob-like coronet and irregular bulbous tubercles on the body. It has a rounded spine above each eye and on each cheek. Two colour morphs are recorded for this species, one is pale greyish-pink with pink or red tubercles, the second is yellow with orange tubercles. Both are found only on gorgonians (sea fans) of the genus
Muricella, in depths of 16-40m. The Pygmy Seahorse grows to 2cm in length. It is remarkably well camouflaged. The colour of the Seahorse matches the gorgonian it inhabits, and the body tubercles look very similar to the polyps of the gorgonian. There are claims that the tubercules on the pygmies are actually live coral polyps growing on the skin.
Bargibant's Pygmy Seahorse (Hippocampus bargibanti)We came across the Bargibant's pygmies on the
Muricella gorgornian fans at a depth of about 22m along the vertical walls of this site. This is the common pink colour morph. There were about 2 of them on this seafan of about 1.5cm length and both were not very compliant with photo-taking. At this depth, there was constant current sweeping me and the seafan which makes it even harder to shoot digital stills of them.
Muricella gorgornian have numerous closely knitted polyp tubercles on the extensive tight network of branches, giving the pygmies exceptional camouflage even to the keen eyes. This Pygmy Seahorse is a very shy species and will most certainly turn away from view when cameras approach. Imagine my frustration getting all the backsides and unfocussed shots...
Sea Moth (Eurypegasus draconis)A very cryptic species perfectly camouflaged to match its sandy surroundings. They are usually seen in pairs meandering over the sandy bottom looking for tiny crustaceans and other benthic organisms to feed upon. Their body structures mimics pieces of broken shells and rubble. They looked like a combination of fish, platypus and seahorse(Eurypegasus: Pegasus was the winged horse of Greek mythology). When frightened, they will flare their broad pectoral wing-like fins and meander off very fast, in a synchronised zig-zag fashion changing directions simultaneously.
This particular white and red colour morph of the Warty Frogfish is also known as the Clown Frogfish. This little guy was sitting out in the open blantantly without any sponge cover where it usually conceals itself. It is bright white or yellow with reddish brown and bright orange triangular patterns. The skin is covered with warts and clearly visible pores which makes it look like a piece of sponge. The lure, attached at the front of its head just above its mouth, looks like a small fish.

Clown Frogfish (Antennarius maculatus)
Like all frogfish, it tends to stay in the same area for some time. It can be spotted in the same location for days. The Clown Frogfish will sometimes sit out in the open (like the one I photographed above) pretending to be a small piece of sponge growth. This specimen was about 10cm.
Juvenile Ribbon Eel (Rhinomuraena quaesita)This is the juvenile black and yellow Ribbon Eel. All black juveniles are males. Upon attaining adulthood it will change its colour to electric blue and yellow. A sex change occurs when the blue males transforms into the rarely seen all yellow females.
Juvenile Ribbon Eel (Rhinomuraena quaesita)Like many eels, the ribbon eel is sometimes thought to be angry or aggressive, because its mouth is often agape, appearing ready to strike. In reality, the eel is simply breathing. The ribbon eel buries itself in sand or hides in rocks or reefs, dashing out to feed on small fishes. The ribbon eel is known as one of the most sociable and peaceful of all moray eels, and does not bother humans or easily get irritated.
Demon Stinger (Inimicus sinensis)Also called the Devil Scorpionfish, this demon can inflict horrendous wounds causing excruciating pain with their venomous spines. Its pectoral fins are modified with free finger-like rays, enabling it to walk across the sandy bottom and to use it to bury itself in the sand. It has a short tail that is held at a cramped angle to the lumpy, spiny body. A cluster of fringed, disarrayed and long dorsal spines rises from its back. When threatened, it will display menacingly, flaring the inside of its beautiful and stunningly coloured pectoral fins as a strong sign of warning. The different species of devilfishes
(Inimicus didactylus, filamentosus, caledonicus and sinensis) are differentiated apart from the colour of their pectoral fins.
Strapweed Filefish (Pseudomonacanthus macrurus)Also known as the Smallspotted Leatherjacket, it is a marbled brown filefish, highly variable in colour. Almost always visible scattered black spots and an obvious white blotch next to the pectoral fins. Short seaweed shaped skin flaps cover the whole body and the dorsal spine.
Banggai Cardinalfish (Pterapogon kauderni) The Banggai Cardinalfish, also known as the Kaudern's Cardinal, or Longfin Cardinalfish, is beige and silver highlighted by black stripes and white spots on the body with long, elegant fins. As its name suggests, they are native to the Banggai islands in Central Eastern Sulawesi, Indonesia. There have been successful introduction of this unique species in recent years to other locations in the vicinity. They have invaded and are thriving well in Lembeh Strait, north of Banggai islands.
A Clown Anemonefish amidst a school of Banggai Cardinalfish
Banggai Cardinalfish is active during daylight hours, while many of its fellow
Apogonidae are nocturnal. All male Cardinalfish species incubate their eggs in their mouths while the females guard their males aggressively. They release their youngs into the planktonic layer when they hatch. But the Banggai Cardinalfish is the only species of its kind to continue housing their fry in the male parents' mouth for another 10 days or so after they hatch. This dedicated parental care means their productivity level is much lower than other species of Cardinalfish. They are usually found in groups of around 2 to 20 individuals, sheltering among structures such as branching corals, sea urchin spines and seagrass stems. Some even associate with sea anemones. They hover just above the tentacles, but are able to make contact without harm, similar to the commensal relationship between a Clown Anemonefish and their Anemone hosts.
Peacock Mantis Shrimp (Odontodactylus scyllarus)One of the most beautiful and interesting species of its kind, this powerful "smasher" can split a human finger open with a lightning-fast strike of its modified raptorial claws. It is a very active predator often hunting out in the open for crustaceans, molluscs and even fish, easily recognised by its aposematic bright colouration. Often difficult to photograph in the open as it scuffles for hiding in coral rubble or retreat to its typical U-shaped, 2 exits burrow. When cornered (like the one above), it will stand up and watch the photographer, sometimes rolling on its back and showing off its beautiful tail fan. This and other Mantis Shrimps must never be touched or get too close to, as they are quite capable of smashing through a camera lens housing with a force and speed of a .22 caliber bullet!!
Peacock Mantis Shrimp (Odontodactylus scyllarus)An extraordinary species that looks like a combination of Shrimp and Praying Mantis with beautiful feathery colouration of a Peacock. A ravishing but deadly beauty.
Shireen's Phyllidiopsis (Phyllidiopsis shireenae)A Nudibranch of the family,
Phyllidiidae. They do not have branchial plumes on their dorsal surface. Phyllidiids hide their gills underneath their mantle skirt.
Phyllidiopsis shireenae is distinctive, on account of its mid-dorsal crest (i.e., the body is not dorsoventrally flattened as in other phyllidiids). It is white(sometimes very pale pink coloration) with a few black lines, and salmon pink rhinophores. No other Phyllidiid possesses a large dorsal crest and salmon pink rhinophores.
Babai's Phyllidia (Phyllidia babai) As described by Brunckhorst, 1993....The '
Phyllidia ocellata colour group' is a particularly complex one having slugs with yellow-orange tubercles and/or dorsum with 'eye patches' surrounded in white and or black with a tubercle (usually yellow) in the middle. While
P. ocellata displays some individual variation some other distinct species occur in the colour group.
Phyllidia babai belongs to this group. It is distinguishable by its consistently white dorsum with fine yellow margin and narrow tubercles; it has the black 'eye patches' as other species in the group. There are other distinguishing features such as its white foot (dark gray in
P. ocellata) and in internal morphology and morphology of penial spines.
P. babai is known from the western pacific; it feeds on the yellow sponge,
Acanthella stipata. This nudibranch was named in honour of a grand gentleman of Opisthobranch taxonomy and biology in Japan, Kikutaro Baba.
Morose Tambja (Tambja morosa)This is a large species of
Tambja growing to about 70mm long. It is usually black, dark blue or green with bright blue markings. Like all species of
Tambja, it feeds on arborescent (plant-like) bryozoan colonies. This elongated species of
Tambja are capable of 'swimming' (more of riding on currents) to quickly get mobile in search of food or escape predators. They swim by vigorous lateral movement of the body - simultaneously bending the head and tail to one side, then to the other. Not a very directed way of swimming but a good way to move away from somewhere quickly.
Red-Gilled Nembrotha (Nembrotha rutilans)A typically coloured
Nembrotha rutilans is with creamy-white body, large brown/maroon patches anterior and posterior to the gills, orange-red patch on the tail, purplish blue oral tentacles, long red rhinophores and very large red gills. The characteristic blue line along the edge of the foot appears faint gray in my specimen, however. This species typically displays a dramatic cobra or rattlesnake striking posture. It feeds on the slowest moving of benthic invertebrates, a sessile tunicate.
Loch's Chromodoris (Chromodoris lochi)This is the blue complex with orange-yellow gills variation of the
Chromodoris lochi. This rare colour form are easily confused with
C. willani,
C. dianae,
C. annae and
C. elisabethina. To distinguish
C. lochi from the other 4 species
Chromodorids, study carefully at the colouration and markings of its mantle, branchial plume and its rhinophores. C. lochi have either an all white or speckled blue(this case) mantle and foot. Its rhinophores and gills are within an unbroken black perimeter on the mantle. It also has a black median line which can be discontinous. It either is a blue mantle complex form which is always coupled with all orange-yellow rhinophores and gills, or, it will be an all white mantle form with white or pink rhinophores and gills. Both colour forms of the
C. lochi always have a bright white mantle skirting edge.
Loch's Chromodoris (Chromodoris lochi) This on the other hand is the more typical form of the
Loch's Chromodoris. It has a feathery white branchial plume and pinkish rhinophores. The mantle skirt is all white without any orange or yellow marginal band. It feed on sponges.
Anna's Chromodoris (Chromodoris annae)It has a blue or sometimes bluish white background, with fine black punctate notum. Black line alla around the mantle. It has distinctive brilliant orange rhinophores and gills. An orange band surrounds the mantle edge. This species can be differentiated from the similar looking
C. elisabethina by not having a longitudinal black median line.
C. annae has black punctation while
C. elisabethina has black pitted marks against blue background.

Electric Flame Scallop (Lima scabra) The Electric Flame Scallop is an extremely beautiful molluscs that has a bright red mantle with long, red and flowing tentacles. The species seems to create electricity which can be seen jolting across its mantle like lightning bolts. These electrical surges are bright enough to be seen by our naked eye. The shell of the Flame Scallops is covered with fine bumps, making it feel like a file. It likes to hide in rock crevices and caves with its shell embeded in the substrate. Capable of shooting strong jets of water out of its mantle while closing its shell to propel away from predators. It is a filter feeder that dines on phytoplanktons. Here is an interesting video that I captured to illustrate this strange electrical phenomenon which left me in awe!
Play it to be electrified!
2 Trumpetfishes cruised near the water surface with beautiful rays of sunburst illuminating the colours of the pristine reefs at Nudi Retreat.
We ended this dive at the small cove of Nudi Retreat, with amazing colours of the reef illuminated by the rays of sunburst shooting through the water surface - an exchanted experience!
The "Beach with a well" is a Site with full of wealth! Pantai Perigi lies on Lembeh island just close to the huge white limestone formations. The name can be translated to "beach with a well". There's a private beach at this site, but we didn't explore the dry land site to see if there's really a well here. We started the dive on a gentle slope with light grey sand. Towards deeper waters, it's mostly muck with obsuring visibility. There were only ocassional patches of soft corals among the murky bottom. But almost under every rock, log, rubbish and corals, lurked critters of all sorts. There were some hard and soft coral colonnies in the upper area of the dive site.
This site is one of my best muck dive. There were countless bizzare but interesting animals all over this splendid location. I encountered so many animals on my wishlists and they are just so fascinating. I was so engrossed in taking pictures most of my time and lost my buddiess few times but we always managed to find one another everytime.

Top side pictures of Pentai Perigi with me posing next to Nodi...and Michelle Dive Site: Pantai PerigiLocation: Lembeh StraitVisibilty: 5 mTemperature: 27°CMaximum Depth: 20.7 m
Dwarf Lionfish (Dendrochyrus brachypterus)As its name implies this species of lionfish is one of the smallest sized with individual growing to a maximum length of 15 cm. They are often found in small aggregations on coastal reefs especially on silty bottoms and among vegetation debris. They show variable colouration and when disturbed, it will readily flare its brightly coloured aposematic fan-like pectoral fins. Like all other Lionfish, this menacing and grumpy looking fish should never be touched by as they are capable of inflicting nasty pain with their venomous spines.
Papuan Scorpionfish (Scorpaenopsis papuensis)A very cryptic bottom ambush predator. It is almost undistinguishable from the very similar
S. oxycephala and
S. possi.
S. papuensis has forward pointing tentacles above the eyes which are absent in the other 2 similar species. It is usually found in coral and rocky areas to depths over 40 m and also in coastal sand slopes, estuaries and lagoons, often in algae covered rubble zones.
Long-horn Cowfish (Lactoria cornuta)The cowfish belong to the Boxfish family of
Ostraciidae. They are aptly named as they have rigid box-shaped body, made up of semi-fused but well defined hexagonal bony plates. A truly armoured box-like strong casing with holes through which emerge the eyes, the mouth, the gills, the fins and the caudal peduncle. Despite a seemingly lack of streamlined flexibility, they are fast and agile swimmers. This particular species of boxfish is called cowfish because it spot a pair of long sharp horns above the eyes and another shorther pair at the lower rear. It is usually solitary, often observed on sand and seagrass bottoms blowing water on sand to uncover the small benthic prey it feeds on.

Hairy Frogfish (Antennarius striatus)Small little frogfish that is covered with developed hair-like dermal appendages as its name suggests. It is a peculiar species that can spot different colour variation, from brownish, yellowish, pinkish to whitish. The background blotches and stripes are always present though. Being an Anglerfish, it has a large, boomerang-shaped lure that looks like a fat worm. It is commonly observed on sandy or silty bottoms with rotting vegetation and sponges where it lies patiently camouflaged for an unsuspecting meal.
Undoubtly, this flounder swam and hugged closely flat to the sandy seabed. Perfectly camouflaged by using its various shades of brown mottled on its ocular side. It will suddenly spread its greatly elongated white dorsal fin rays in front of its head when threatened. Watch the video above that demonstrate this behaviour.
Flying Gurnard (Dactyloptena orientalis)
Watch this clip and see how the Flying Gurnard takes flight. It opened up its colourfully vibrant wing-like pectoral fins to glide across the sandy bed. It is also capable of lightning fast short burst of speed to get away from danger.
Porcelain Crab (Neopetrolisthes maculatus)I have described a very similar and almost identical species of the Porcelain crab previously. It also share the same characteristics and live on the same types of commensalistic anemone hosts. The
N. maculatus can be distinguished from the preceding
N. oshimai by its smaller and more numerous red spots on a white background.

Crinoid Squat Lobster (Allogalathea elegans)A tick-like critter species of variable vibrant colours, always matching to its crinoid hosts. It has a flattened oval body with a long pointed rostum. Alone or more often in pairs living exclusively and having commensalistic relationship with its featherstar hosts. They are often found underneath the crinoids and can be observed by gently tickling (with a dive rod) the hosts' underside to make them open up. Never attempt to handle the crinoids with hands as the featherstars' arms are extremely fragile and they will break and stick to your skin.
Red-striped Cleaner Shrimp (Lysmatella prima)Clearly identified by its bright yellow legs, the body is also yellowish, striped in bright red. This species does not seem to mind when closely approached and will often stay out in the open in true "cleaner" fashion. It is supremely confident in its bold colouration to ward off predators and advertises its cleaner services to would-be passing customers.

Commensal Shrimp (Periclemenes magnificus)This particular species of cleaner commensal shrimp was described in an earlier post. This is a much clearer and close-up macro shot of it. The best part is it was impregnated with eggs visible through its transparent abdomen.
Blue Dragon (Pteraeolidia ianthina)A solar powered nudibranch of variable colour, its cerata stores undigested and uncharged stinging nematocysts capable of painful stings if touched. It also culture zooxanthellae from its diet and stores them in its cerata. In the nudibranch's body, the zooxanthellae get protection and in turn provides the nudibranch with nutrients from photosynthesis. Young animals are white as they have yet to develop their crop of zooxanthellae. Adults often can go without feeding for sometime, possibly living off the nutrients provided by the zooxanthallae.
Mt Dua Saudara - an inactive volcano at the heart of BitungWe finished the last dive at about 1530 hrs North Sulawesi time and began our hour long journey back to Barracuda resort. We were so tired that we slept throughout the journey. When we reached our resort, it was still too early for dinner so we showered and headed out to the Mega Mall in Manado town. Our poor driver can't really communicate in English yet he had to follow us around while we did our shopping. I think we bored him alot as we were taking our time forever to window shop....
We returned to the resort for dinner and coincidently, my OW instructor from Big Bubble Center, Singapore, arrived at the Barracuda with his students. What a timely meet in a foreign paradisa! It was bedtime after some catch up session with Stanley and we looked forward to more deep blue diving the next day...
To be continued...